Election newsCivic3 min read

Every Douglas County Ballot Has a Train Tax on It. Only 5,967 Voters Were Supposed to Get One.

All 289,000 Douglas County ballots carry Ballot Issue 7A, the Front Range Passenger Rail sales tax, when only 5,967 voters in Sterling Ranch are supposed to vote on it. The clerks were never sent the district's new boundary; the district's general manager says that is on him; the state says those votes will not be counted.

By Discover DougCo Editorial Team··

If your Douglas County ballot has a question about a train on it and you do not live in Sterling Ranch, you are looking at a mistake. Not yours. Every one of the county's roughly 289,000 ballots went out with Ballot Issue 7A printed on it, 9NEWS reported Wednesday night, when under the rail district's redrawn boundary only 5,967 voters in Sterling Ranch should have gotten the question. The same thing happened in Adams, Arapahoe and Weld counties, about 800,000 voters in all, because the four clerks were never sent the district's new map and printed from the old one.

What 7A is

The Front Range Passenger Rail District wants to run a train called the Colorado Connector from Pueblo to Fort Collins, with a stop in Sterling Ranch between Colorado Springs and Littleton. To pay for it, the district's board voted on August 28 to put a tax question to its voters: a one-third-of-a-penny sales tax, which the ballot language says would raise $295 million a year, plus $580 million in borrowing with a total repayment cost of $785 million. Groceries, gasoline, home utilities and prescriptions are exempt. 9NEWS puts the cost at 10 cents on a $30 purchase. Our full breakdown of 7A is on the statewide measures page.

Why most of Douglas County is not supposed to see it

Because the legislature redrew the district this spring. Senate Bill 172, signed in May, shrank the rail district to 31 cities along the route plus, in Douglas County, the Sterling Ranch Metropolitan District. Castle Rock and Lone Tree came out. Highlands Ranch, Parker and most unincorporated Douglas County are out too. The sponsor's logic, as the Colorado Sun reported it, was to keep the cities where at least a fifth of residents live within five miles of a planned station.

The detail that stings now: one reason lawmakers gave for the redraw was that county clerks had said the old boundaries "are too difficult to use for elections." The new, simpler boundary is the one that got printed wrong.

What went wrong

A ballot is assembled by style. Every address in the county gets a ballot carrying exactly the races and questions that address is eligible for; Weld County alone has 443 styles, its clerk told 9NEWS last month. 7A was supposed to appear on the Sterling Ranch styles and no others. What happened instead, per 9NEWS's Wednesday report, is simpler and worse: the clerks in Douglas, Adams, Arapahoe and Weld were never given the district's new 31-city boundary, so they built their ballots from the original 13-county map, in which all of Douglas County was inside the district. Douglas County says it put 7A on the ballots of the voters it was told should receive it. El Paso County's clerk, Steve Schleiker, did it differently: after hearing nothing from the district he pulled the boundaries straight out of Senate Bill 26-172 and printed 7A only in Colorado Springs and Manitou Springs. "To me, this falls on the district," he said.

The district's general manager, Sal Pace, agreed, with a footnote. "I'm taking personal responsibility here," he told 9NEWS. "Myself, or someone on our staff on my behalf, should have called up every single one of the clerks and said, 'Do you know exactly what the lines are?' I'm taking responsibility for that, even though it was not in our enabling legislation." The law that shrank the district did not assign anyone the job of telling the clerks. Adams County's clerk, Josh Zygielbaum: "Ultimately, the responsibility falls to the district." Arapahoe's elections director, Bill Mast: "It is the responsibility of the rail district to provide that notice to us." Pace said he searched his inbox and found no emails from any of them. Asked whether the district would pull 7A and try again another year, he said he had heard nothing from his board to that effect.

Douglas County mailed ballots on October 2. They were already in mailboxes when the error surfaced.

The district has a second problem this week. Complete Colorado reported Tuesday that Cory Gaines, an eastern Colorado resident the district had recruited as one of its volunteer "CoCo Conductors," filed a campaign-finance complaint with the Secretary of State accusing the district of spending nearly $2 million in public money on advertising that amounts to advocacy for 7A. The district's general manager told the outlet the spending was educational, not advocacy.

How the fix works

On Wednesday night the Secretary of State's elections director, Judd Choate, sent the four clerks their instructions, reported Thursday morning by the Denver Gazette. The counties must "not tabulate votes cast for or against Front Range Passenger Rail District Ballot Issue 7A by voters who are not registered in the municipalities and metropolitan districts" inside the redrawn boundary. Nobody gets a new ballot. Instead each county configures its counting system to tally 7A only from eligible voters, and the state is sending testing protocols later this week.

For most of the wrongly printed ballots that is a sorting problem the machines can handle, because an ineligible voter's ballot style is different from an eligible one's. The exception is the one that matters here. In two places, Bow Mar in Arapahoe County and Sterling Ranch in Douglas County, a single ballot style covers both people who are in the district and people who are not. Those envelopes get out-stacked by the sorter for hand review. "Those eligible to vote in the race will be processed as normal," Choate wrote. "Those ineligible will be signature verified, deconstructed, and then duplicated onto a ballot style that does not include 7A." The Gazette's headline word is "hand review," and it stresses this is not a hand count.

The Gazette puts the number of voters in the four counties who were sent ballots with the question at some 800,000; it does not break that out by county.

What we still do not know

  • What the Douglas County Clerk's office will say in its own words. As of Thursday it has issued no statement; 9NEWS reports the county "maintains that it put 7A on the ballots to the voters who are supposed to receive it."
  • What "deconstructed and duplicated" costs in time for the Sterling Ranch envelopes, and whether it delays Douglas County's count on election night. Counties begin processing ballots October 19.
  • Whether the district's board pulls the question. Its general manager says he has heard nothing to suggest it will.
  • Whether the error affects the Sterling Ranch ballots themselves. Nothing in the reporting so far says it does.
  • Who, between the clerks, the Secretary of State and the rail district, owns the mistake. So far only the Secretary of State's Office has spoken. To 9NEWS it said the clerks should have worked with the district on the boundary; in its written statement to Denver7 it said 7A went on more ballots "than it should have been following the adoption of SB 26-172," the boundary law.

Nothing in 9NEWS's report or the Secretary of State's confirmation suggests any other race or question on the ballot is affected.

If 7A is on your ballot

If you live in Sterling Ranch, 7A is yours to vote on. If you live anywhere else in Douglas County, 7A is printed on your ballot and you are one of the 283,000 or so voters this story is about. Adams County's clerk put the remedy plainly: "We just don't report those results." Arapahoe's elections director said anyone who wants to watch that happen can sign up as an official observer through a party, a candidate or an issue committee. Leave 7A blank. Under the state's instructions, a mark on 7A from outside the district is not counted either way, and a blank keeps your ballot out of the hand-review stack if it can be. The rest of the ballot does not wait for any of this. The clerk's office is at 303-660-7444 and douglasco.gov/elections. We will update this page when the county says how many ballots are affected and what it intends to do.

More: every race and measure on your ballot, the November ballot guide, and your sample ballot line by line.

Election night: live results for every Douglas County race, measure and judge, with the first numbers after 7 p.m. on Nov. 3. Before then: where to vote in person, every drop box, and the deadlines, and who has voted so far.

The results: what to know the morning after

Sources

Local DougCo news worth your inbox

We dig into the Douglas County stories — elections, development, what's opening — that the big outlets skip. Free, no spam.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Comments

Sign in with Google to comment

Loading comments…